TrainingBehavior and adherence

The Habit Loop: Making Exercise Automatic

3 minute read

Quick Intro

A habit is a behavior triggered automatically by a cue, with little conscious thought. The habit loop is a simple model of this process with three parts: a cue, a routine and a reward. The model was popularized by the writer Charles Duhigg in 2012, building on research in psychology and neuroscience. Habits matter for exercise, because a behavior that runs automatically needs less willpower.

The Idea in Plain Terms

The loop works like this:

PartWhat it isExample
CueA trigger in the environment or routineAlarm rings, shoes by the door
RoutineThe behaviorA 20-minute walk
RewardSomething that makes the behavior worth repeatingFeeling energized, a favorite podcast, ticking a box

With repetition in the same setting, the link between cue and behavior strengthens. Over time the cue alone prompts the action. Psychologists such as Wendy Wood describe habits as context-dependent: they form in a stable setting and weaken when the setting changes, which is why habits break during travel.

Rewards are important in the early stage. A behavior that feels good or gives a sense of accomplishment is repeated. Later, the behavior can continue even when the reward is small.

A common claim is that it takes 21 days to form a habit. The number comes from a 1960 book by a plastic surgeon, Maxwell Maltz, about how patients adjusted to their new appearance, and has no basis in habit research.

A Worked Example

Building a morning stretching habit:

PartChoice
CueAfter brushing teeth
RoutineFive minutes of stretching
RewardA cup of coffee afterward, plus ticking a calendar

The anchor to an existing habit, brushing teeth, makes the cue reliable.

What the Research Shows

A 2010 study by Lally and colleagues in the European Journal of Social Psychology followed 96 volunteers as they tried to make a new eating, drinking or exercise behavior a daily habit. The time it took for the behavior to feel automatic ranged from 18 to 254 days, with a median of 66 days. Missing a single day did not significantly derail the process. Complex behaviors, such as exercise, took longer than simple ones, such as drinking a glass of water.

Reviews of habit-based interventions suggest that forming exercise habits is possible, and that effects on behavior are moderate. The Duhigg version of the model is a simplification of a larger body of work, and researchers debate how well it applies to complex behaviors such as going to the gym.

Who It Suits

This model helps:

  • People who struggle with consistency.
  • Those starting a new routine.
  • Coaches who help clients build routines.

How to Use It

  1. Pick a specific cue, such as a time or an existing habit.
  2. Start with a small version of the behavior.
  3. Do it in the same place and at the same time.
  4. Add a small reward.
  5. Be patient: automaticity takes weeks to months.
  6. Return to the routine the day after a miss.

Common Misunderstandings

It is not true that habits form in 21 days.

It is not necessary to be perfect.

It is not the same as motivation.

FAQ

How long does a habit take? About two months on average, with wide variation.

What if I miss a day? One miss has little effect.

Does a big goal help? Small steps often work better early.

Why do habits break when I travel? The cues change.

Where This Comes From

Lally P, van Jaarsveld CHM, Potts HWW and Wardle J, 2010, how are habits formed: modelling habit formation in the real world (European Journal of Social Psychology, 40, 998 to 1009). Wood W and Neal DT, 2007, a new look at habits and the habit-goal interface (Psychological Review, 114, 843 to 863). Duhigg C, 2012, The Power of Habit.


Related to: implementation intentions, self-determination theory and sleep and recovery.